Renovation: Does this choice of materials cost twice as much?
Hello, Lionel here. The cheapest option can end up costing twice as much if the material needs to be replaced quickly or requires a complex installation. To avoid this, compare the total cost over time: purchase, installation, maintenance and any eventual removal.
When renovating, a low price tag therefore doesn’t guarantee that your project budget will stay under control. Quality matters, but so do the room’s intended use, compatibility with what’s already there and labor costs.
Good habits to adopt
- Compare the installed cost, not just the price of the material.
- Check its lifespan and maintenance requirements based on how it will be used.
- Ask for specific alternatives in each renovation quote.
- Avoid making changes in the middle of the project, as these often lead to cost overruns.
- Set aside a 10–15% contingency for unexpected costs.
To guide your choice of materials, consult this guide to renovation materials. You can also compare expense categories using this estimate of the cost of a complete renovation.
The cheapest material can drive up the final bill
Material costs are only part of the calculation. A budget-grade finish may require more preparation, wear out quickly or be unsuitable for a damp room. If the work has to be redone, you’ll have to pay again for removal, materials and installation.
Imagine Léa, who is renovating an apartment to rent out. She chooses an inexpensive floor to save money upfront, but it doesn’t stand up well to frequent foot traffic. A few years later, replacing it means emptying the rooms and redoing the finishing work: the initial savings disappear.
Conversely, always choosing the most expensive material is no guarantee of better value for money. The key is to select a solution suited to how often it will be used, the level of humidity, the maintenance you can manage and the contractor’s expertise.
Which costs can push your renovation budget over the limit?
In a complete renovation, expenses aren’t limited to visible finishes. Demolition and structural work can account for around 10–20% of the budget, while the second-fix work—plumbing, electrical, heating and insulation—can take up 25–40%. The proportions vary depending on the condition of the property and the scope of the work.
Kitchens and bathrooms often involve expensive fixtures, connections and specialist installation. In these rooms, an unsuitable material can lead to repairs far more costly than a simple decorative replacement.
| Expense category | Indicative share of the budget | What to check |
|---|---|---|
| Demolition and structural work | 10 to 20% | Condition of the structure, access and rubble removal |
| Second-fix work | 25 to 40% | Code compliance, insulation and fixtures |
| Interior fit-out | 15 to 25% | Quality of finishes and installation complexity |
| Kitchen and bathroom | 10 to 20% | Product range, layout and connections |
| Indirect costs and contingencies | 10 to 15% | Surveys, administrative procedures and unforeseen issues |
Structural, soil or energy-efficiency surveys may be needed before certain major works. Depending on the project, a prior planning application or building permit may also involve fees and delays: it’s best to factor these in during the planning stage rather than discover them partway through the work.
Durable materials: consider the cost over time
A durable material may cost more upfront while reducing the need for replacements and maintenance. For example, tiles designed for a high-traffic area may be a better choice than a cheaper but fragile floor covering. For a wall that won’t see much use, a simpler option may be enough.
Installation matters just as much. A demanding or heavy material, or one that must be installed according to specific rules, can increase labor costs. Ask the contractor to clearly separate the cost of materials, surface preparation and installation so you can compare quotes on the same basis.
Renovation materials must also be compatible with the building. An impermeable finish applied to an old surface that needs to breathe can cause problems; the upfront saving can then turn into a costly repair. The right choice depends on the property’s context, not just on a sample in a store.
A three-step method to keep renovation costs under control
- Define what you need. Note the room, how it will be used, any moisture or foot-traffic constraints and the level of maintenance you’re willing to take on.
- Compare three detailed quotes. Ask for material specifications, quantities, required preparation, installation and warranties. A very low quote may leave out services or include a different product range.
- Make your decisions before work begins. Approve the finishes and fixtures in advance, then keep a 10–15% contingency for anything uncovered during the work.
Also avoid changing the project as the work progresses: each change can mean a new order, extra labor or a delay to the schedule. If you’re thinking of doing some of the work yourself, stick to tasks you can genuinely handle; a mistake involving waterproofing or electrical work can cost more than hiring a professional.
Practical questions to ask before choosing your materials
Is the cheapest material always a bad choice?
No. It may be suitable for a low-traffic area or temporary use. However, compare its installed cost, durability and maintenance requirements before deciding.
How much should I set aside for unexpected costs?
A contingency of 10 to 15% of the estimated cost of the work is generally recommended, especially in an older property where the condition of the surfaces may hold surprises.
How do I compare two renovation quotes?
Check that they describe the same work, the same quantities and materials of a comparable grade. Also check the preparation, installation, timelines and the contractor’s insurance.
Should I always choose high-end materials?
No. The best value for money depends on the room, how it will be used and how long you plan to live there. Spend more where durability or performance really matters.
Thanks for reading! Feel free to share your thoughts in the comments. — Lionel





